Tags
Albert Einstein, Albert Einstein: His Life and Universe, America and Americans, Bertrand Russell, conflict, democracy, England Your England, Eugene Debs, Fascism, Genus Americanus, George Orwell, Government, John Steinbeck, March, Marching, Military, nonfiction, Pacifism, Patriotism, peace, politics, protest, Rosa Luxemburg, Socialism, Spectacle, Walter Isaacson, War, Why I Write
“When troops would come by, accompanied by fifes and drums, kids would pour into the streets to join the parade and march in lockstep. But not Einstein. Watching such a display once, he began to cry. ‘When I grow up, I don’t want to be one of those poor people,’ he told his parents. As Einstein later explained, ‘When a person can take pleasure in marching in step to a piece of music it is enough to make me despise him. He has been given his big brain only by mistake.'”
Albert Einstein, as described in chapter 2 (“Childhood, 1879-1896”) of Walter Isaacson’s biography Einstein: His Life and Universe.
“One rapid but fairly sure guide to the social atmosphere of a country is the parade-step of its army. A military parade is really a kind of ritual dance, something like a ballet, expressing a certain philosophy of life. The goose-step, for instance, is one of the most horrible sights in the world, far more terrifying than a dive-bomber. It is simply an affirmation of naked power; contained in it, quite consciously and intentionally, is the vision of a boot crashing down on a face. Its ugliness is part of its essence, for what it is saying is ‘Yes, I am ugly, and you daren’t laugh at me’, like the bully who makes faces at his victim.
Why is the goose-step not used in England? In the British army… the march is merely a formalized walk. It belongs to a society which is ruled by the sword, no doubt, but a sword which must never be taken out of the scabbard.”
George Orwell, reflecting in a segment from his essay “England Your England,” which is published in his collection of essays Why I Write.
“It is a strange thing how Americans love to march if they don’t have to. Every holiday draws millions marchers, sweating in the sun, some falling and being carted away to hospitals. In hardship and in some danger they will march… but let the Army take them and force them to march, and they wail like hopeless kelpies on a tidal reef, and it requires patience and enormous strictness to turn them into soldiers.
Once they give in, they make very good soldiers; but they never cease their complaints and their mutinous talk. This, of course, does not describe our relatively small class of professional soldiers: they are like professionals in any army; but national need calls up the citizen soldier, and he is a sight. He kicks like a steer going in, bitches the whole time, fights very well when he is trained and properly armed…”
John Steinbeck, writing in his essay “Genus Americanus,” which can be found in his last published book, America and Americans.
__________
If you have additional references or ideas relating to this topic, please send them my way or post them in the comments section.
During the First World War, prominent public figures in all three of these men’s home countries were jailed for not marching in lock-step into the conflict. Because she opposed the war and had become one of the figureheads of the German socialist movement, Rosa Luxemburg spent most of the war in prison and was eventually murdered by German soldiers in 1919. In England, Bertrand Russell was thrown into Brixton Prison for six months for “passive resistance to military or naval service.” And in the United States, the famous union leader and five-time presidential candidate Eugene Debs was charged with ten counts of sedition for making an anti-draft speech on June 16th, 1918. He was eventually sentenced to ten years in prison and was disenfranchised for life.
If you’d like to read more from Steinbeck, check out another selection from America and Americans, in which he points out a curious paradox at the heart of how Americans appraise their presidents: “The President must be greater than anyone else, but not better than anyone else…”
Or, see more from Isaacson’s biography of A.E., including a page describing Einstein’s obsession with identifying the causality behind the laws of nature. “When I am judging a theory… I ask myself whether, if I were God, I would have arranged the world in such a way?”
julienmatei said:
Thanks for this post. A lot to be said…
I really wonder:
With few exceptions, human nature seems to be totally defective…
jrbenjamin said:
I often think that too: there’s just no saving us. Still, and I know this reference may be ironic in the context of this military-themed post, General Patton said a great word on this subject: “If a man does his best, what else is there?”
All you can do is try to be one of those exceptions to the amoral herd.
julienmatei said:
Truly wise!
Best,
Julien
navigator1965 said:
Interesting post. You might consider Brigadier-General Sir John Hackett’s book “The Profession of Arms” to get an contrarian insider perspective. Been many years since I read it, so I don’t have a quote at hand.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Hackett_(British_Army_officer)
jrbenjamin said:
Hmm. Thanks for this, I’ll check it out immediately — it’s always great seeing the alternate angles you bring to these posts.
Pingback: The Sovereignty of Politics: Adams, Jefferson, and Krauthammer on Why We Must Study Government | The Bully Pulpit
Pingback: What Happened When Hitler Kicked out Einstein | The Bully Pulpit
Pingback: Hitler Kicks out Einstein | The Bully Pulpit
Pingback: Bernard Baruch: We Need International Law with Teeth | The Bully Pulpit
Roger Gauthier said:
Very interesting article. It would be an fascinating study to see how America has changed it’s marching from the 1st world war to present to see what the evolution has been. Have we gotten better and more compassionate or have we become hardened by the sufferings? It would be enlightening to say the least. BTW…wold you mind if I used the photo of Einstein at the top to create a quote graphic as long as I gave reference to this page?
jrbenjamin said:
That’s fine. Just reference the source.
erzico said:
Reblogged this on Leisure.
Pingback: ‘We Don’t March’: Einstein, Orwell, and Steinbeck on the Evils of Militarism – the Goodnews Journalist Blog